November 7, 2009



Advertisement



Illustration by Ismael Roldan

Choice Lessons

By Tony Shalhoub as told to Erik Sherman, May & June 2004

The man who plays TV’s obsessive-compulsive Monk reveals the secrets of decision-making




Monk isn't me. But there's a little of me in Monk. He has this horrible weakness, an inability to make choices without calculating every possible outcome. If you've seen the USA Network show, you also know that this need to obsess over the details is also his strength. But Monk is fictitious, and most of us could use a better approach to solving problems than worrying them to death. I know I could. If Monk were a real person, I'd sit him down and tell him a thing or two.

To begin with, there are no wrong decisions. Some people have this idea that in life there is door number one and door number two, and behind door number one is a Cadillac and behind door number two is a pile of manure. Not true. If you hesitate, guess where the manure is? Up to your knees. Here's an example: I was young. I had just finished doing a Broadway play, The Heidi Chronicles, and was offered a part in another one, Lost in Yonkers. I turned it down, thinking this was the time for me to go to Los Angeles.

When I got there, it was disastrous. I sat in L.A. for months without work. And the play I had turned down became a huge success, winning a Tony award for Kevin Spacey. In my role! I felt terrible for making the wrong choice.

More 'Master Class' Articles
AARP The Magazine's regular "Master Class" column invites celebrities and experts in a variety of fields to share their secrets for enjoying and/or succeeding at specific activities. Read these previous columns to learn how to:

    • Enjoy the Night Sky, by space shuttle pilot Col. Eileen Collins
    • Give a Great Speech, by Mario Cuomo

Turns out, it wasn't the wrong choice, but it took me a long time to realize it. It was in L.A. that I discovered the love of my life, Brooke Adams, who's now my wife. I first met Brooke in New York when she costarred with me in The Heidi Chronicles. But I knew her only in relation to work. She was from L.A. and returned after the play closed. If I had stayed in New York, I might never have seen her again.

So, after I finished feeling sorry for myself about missing that Broadway opportunity, I was able to stop obsessing about my career. Plain and simple, my life became more balanced, my health improved, and, not being tense all the time, I was able to do better in auditions. Soon I got my first TV role. Then, in two years, I started getting movie roles and was in Wings, my first TV series. But it wouldn't have happened if I hadn't realized that I needed perspective.

Even a clearly wrong decision can steer you in the right direction. In my early 30s, there was a woman I had been with for a long time. There was always that question of whether we would actually tie the knot, but something kept holding me back. Finally, I proposed anyway—I thought that the right feelings would follow. They didn't. As it happened, not long after we were engaged, the relationship fell apart. But we couldn't have gotten to that point unless that first step was taken.

I still have trouble making decisions, but, with experience, it's a little bit easier now. When I'm at a crossroads, I tell myself whichever path I choose and whatever happens, I'll figure out a way to make things work. I don't think Monk is ever going to learn that lesson. If he did, he wouldn't be as interesting a character. Just a happier person.

Erik Sherman writes about personalities, business, technology, travel, and more.